Unsalted Butter Vs Salted Butter In Baking

Does it matter which kind of butter we use while baking and cooking? Here, we decide whether butter should be salted or unsalted.

Everybody has their go-to recipes when it relates to baking. Many of us have favourite bags of chocolate chips and are steadfast in the kinds of vanilla we purchase. 

Even if it’s just whatever is on sale, you probably have a favourite brand of butter. But are you selecting the proper type of butter for your favourite baking recipe, for example, cake or butter cookies—salted vs. unsalted?

When it concerns pie crusts, cookies, cakes, cupcakes, pound cake, and any other baked goods, salted and unsalted butter are your best buddies in the kitchen. 

Because butter appears in so many of our baked goods recipes, we frequently take it for granted. If the butter is too heated, there is no point in creaming it; the result will be a dense, lifeless cake.

If it’s too cold, the otherwise flawless cake batter will end up with harsh butter pieces. 

Butter’s salt concentration is a huge unanswered question, in addition to its temperature. Ironically, a recipe can ask for both salt and unsalted butter. Sometimes a recipe calls for unsalted butter over salted butter.

This article will answer the age old question in baking: should you use salted or unsalted butter, and what is the difference between them? Are there any differences in brands or taste?

Salted Vs Unsalted Butter

Obviously, salt makes a difference between salted and unsalted butter. While salted butter is made up entirely of cream, the amount of salt added differs from product to product. 

The general rule is that the butter flavor doesn’t really change much, though. And you probably won’t get the taste of too much salt if you use butter with added salt.

Salted butter has a longer shelf life so it keeps better in the fridge for longer—typically five months vs three months for unsalted—because salt is a preservative.

Additionally, this implies that when you visit a supermarket, chances are the unsalted butter is a little fresher than salted butter – but butter with more salt will keep for longer.

You already know that baking is a science, but it’s also a science of control. When using an unsalted variety of butter in a dish, you have complete control over the exact amount of salt which is added – unlike salted butter. 

Because the amount of salt in each type of salted butter you see at the supermarket varies, you have little or no clue how much salt you’re using. 

We can find out the actual salt content of well-known brands, and some brands have twice as much salt as others!

Although it would take lots of butter to noticeably alter the flavour of baked items, it’s still beneficial to have complete control over the salt content.

Salted butter has a shelf life which is much longer than unsalted butter because salt is a preservative. Three to four months are the shelf life of unsalted types of butter.

This doesn’t necessarily imply that it’s been on the shelves for longer. 

Choose unsalted butter if you want the most recent batch. Alternatively, create your own! However, some companies flavour unsalted butter with “natural taste,” extending its storability.

It frequently contains lactic acid, which further balances the pH.

The answer is negative if you’re wondering which butter is superior to the others. Versions that are salted and unsalted can both be used in baking and cooking.

They both taste great and create rich, scrumptious meals – and the natural flavor is not affected. There is no difference between popular brands either.

When Should You Use Unsalted Butter?

Unsalted Butter Vs Salted Butter In Baking

Most often, the recipe calls for unsalted butter over salted butter. Unsalted has a really mild, creamy flavour that makes it a fantastic baking ingredient.

Accurate measures are essential in baking to provide the desired flavour and texture. Even tiny amounts of substances, like salt, fall under this. 

Baking recipes are often written using unsalted butter and then ask you to add salt because you can’t be certain of the precise level of salt for each brand of butter in salted butter.

Adding salt yourself and using a taste test allows you to control this.

When Should You Use Salted Butter?

You can use salted butter in a variety of ways. Salt is a pleasant addition to practically every dish because it enhances flavour in dishes. You can use it in lots of baking recipes too.

Use salted butter to make sauces, sauté vegetables, top toast in the morning, or even prepare the ideal Thanksgiving turkey. 

All of these flavours will be greatly enhanced by the small amount of salt in butter. In these circumstances, unsalted butter would supply the necessary fat but not the additional flavour.

Actually, you could use salted butter as a spread or in most popular recipes.

What Happens If Salted Butter Is Used Instead Of Unsalted Butter?

Don’t let the fact that you only have salted butter in your possession stop you from heating up your oven to bake if you have your heart set on cooking a specific dessert that asks for unsalted butter.

Unsalted and salted butter can be used interchangeably. Simply use less of the salt specified in the recipe if it asks for unsalted and extra salt. There is only one change you need to make.

Given the fundamental distinctions and applications for different types of butter, you may find yourself purchasing extra. The next time you go shopping, keep this information in mind.

The only difference between salted vs unsalted butter in baking is that salted butter has been added to it; otherwise, they are both produced of the same Grade AA grade butter. 

Any dish – from sugar cookies to bread can be made with either salted or unsalted butter; however, if a recipe calls for unsalted butter explicitly, it has likely been tried with that butter and is the best option for that specific recipe.

Final Thoughts

With unsalted butter, you have total control over the profile of the dish and add salt yourself. This is crucial in certain baked dishes where the butter’s pure, sweet cream flavour is essential . 

Unsalted butter in baking allows the true, organic flavour of your meals to come through when cooking. But salted butter and unsalted butter can be used in most baked goods.

Have you ever observed when a dish demands unsalted butter be used before salt is added?

The genuine sweet cream flavour of the unsalted butter comes through without any additional salt, allowing you to adjust the amount of salt in the recipe to your preference and make it less or more salty – which brings out the other ingredients.

However, salted butter can add some real flavour to blander dishes and produce a tastier finished product – so, when you’re baking up a storm – simply check what the recipe calls for, but, if you only have one of the types of butters in stock don’t worry, you can still go ahead with baking your dish!

Picture of Kathryn Sewell

Kathryn Sewell

Hi! I'm Kate and I have been baking and cooking for as long as I can remember. I like to share the most interesting tips and recipes I try here on What Kate Baked for you to enjoy. If you have a favorite recipe you'd like to share send it over on social.

About the Author